I like the jacket's style and it fits well. The sleeves have an inner elasticized sleeve to seal the wrists. A few flaw though. It doesn't have an inner pull to seal the waist when it's really windy so the wind goes right up. You have to use your hands in your pockets to tighten the whole jacket around your body to avoid wind. On a non-windy day, it's not too bad. The shoulders and torso are definitely warm. The zipper is kind of cheap so it doesn't zip smoothly and the fabric gets caught in it a lot. But price was right. But if you are annoyed by a zipper, maybe not the coat for you. Kind of wish it had a hidden or removable hood too but the high collar works well. Not for really cold days. More of a fashion-y coat for above zero.